20 Years of Hurt? Bus Deregulation in Greater Manchester

Mayne of Manchester double decker busIt was supposed to have improved services through competition. There was even talk of drivers owning their own buses. Even fare levels were supposed to have fallen, as power moved from the monolithic PTEs and the National Bus Company to the little.

How wrong they were, and how right were Greater Manchester PTE nearly 20 years ago.

Between 1986 – 1993, there was plenty of competition between GM Buses (then a publicly owned Limited company) and the likes of Citibus, Bee Line Buzz Company and other PTE companies. Thirteen years later, we have now seen bus ownership in the UK concentrated between three major companies. As for drivers being owner occupiers of their own vehicles, this never happened. So much for competition and added choice.

Of course, there were some improvements to services, with some operators running minibus services via streets that tested the bigger buses. However, most of these improvements have been undone by rationalisation of evening and Sunday services or withdrawal. Most of the investment in new buses have been designated to profitable routes like the 135, 216 and the 192. It has also become commonplace for other routes to receive older buses, with many being step entrance rather than low floor.

Fare levels have actually increased rather than fell since 1986, except in some cases. The exceptions to this rule are Stagecoach’s ‘Magic Bus’ and ‘Megabus’ service. A shift towards bought on the bus season tickets has seen increased boarding times and longer journeys. One example of this increase is a nine stage fare on the 346 (Ashton – Hyde – Gee Cross), which has increased from 30p under Greater Manchester Transport to £1.50 under Stagecoach Manchester (or £1.30 on First Pioneer).

Rather than increased services, bus deregulation has seen strategically important routes withdrawn. Examples of these are the 400 (Trans-Lancs Express), 562 (Oldham – Halifax) and the 153 (Manchester – Mossley). Only the Wilmslow Road and A6 corridors have seen an increase, with a staggering 30 buses an hour. In the Tameside area, there are few services with 30 buses a day each way.

Over the last two weeks, the Wilmslow Road corridor has become the subject of controversy over competition on the 85/86 routes to Chorlton. This has resulted in Metrolink trams being blocked in Mosley Street, people cutting their journeys short and walking the rest of the journey. There has been some good news over a leaked memo, stating that the buses will be reregulated within two years.  This was revealed in the Manchester Evening News (13/09/2006 edition):

http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/s/223/223028_bus_wars_get_it_sorted.html

The article is also an indictment of how the then Conservative government forced Greater Manchester, other PTEs and local councils to disintegrate in several weeks an integrated and affordable transport system which has served Britain for the best part of fifty years.

Though there has been improvements in information, through ticketing and integration in the last five years, these have come too late to avert a 45% drop in patronage since Sunday 26th October 1986.

Franchising should involve: participation in timetable compilation between councils and bus users; a long term goal towards a standardised bus design; minimum passenger service requirements (including full Bank Holiday services) and a standard livery.

This should be the case in Greater Manchester and the other PTE areas, notably South Yorkshire, where fares have gone from being the cheapest to being more expensive than Greater Manchester’s.

In Greater Manchester, the future was, is, and remains white, orange and brown.

2 thoughts on “20 Years of Hurt? Bus Deregulation in Greater Manchester

Add yours

  1. Totally agree, deregulation was the biggest of the Thatcher governments many foul ups. A total mess, The clock should literally be turned back and the whole of public transport renationalized, Stagecoach/First Group and Arriva should be closed down and their buses given to a reconstituted Greater Manchester Transport.

    Paint them orange and white again, not the later livery which incorporated brown, that was awful

    Like

  2. Hi David,

    Thank you for your reply. I too was a fan of the original orange and white livery, and would love to see the return of GMT.

    The 1974 – 80 livery still looks striking today, even amid a desert of First’s ‘Barbie’ livery, Stagecoach’s swirls and Arriva’s cow horns. I blame (in a nice way) GMT for me liking the colour orange, and the Helvetica typeface.

    Sadly, the only part of the UK where transport is still in government hands is in the Isle of Man. All buses, trams and steam trains are ran by their Department of Transport, answerable to the House of Keys. Nearly all services are operated with double deckers less than 5 – 10 years old – though fares are more expensive than Greater Manchester (due to their low income tax rate of 15%).

    Stuart.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: